Parasite may have felled a mighty T. rex
Skull holes in several dinosaur specimens are consistent with those found in diseased birds
Web edition : Tuesday, September 29th, 2009
font_down font_up Text Size
access
DINO KILLER?A parasite may have caused slow starvation in several T. rex. Shown here are holes in the jaw of Peck's Rex (skull, far right) and accompanying lesions (artist’s illustration, left) that might have caused them. Renderings by Chris Glen, University of Queensland

Talk about a cold case. The culprit behind a 67-million-year-old murder may be exposed at last. A common avian parasite may have brought down one of the world’s most famous Tyrannosaurus rex dinosaurs, a study appearing online September 29 in PLoS ONE suggests.

Formally known as FMNH PR2081, Sue is the largest and best-preserved T. rex specimen in the world. Although scientists know a lot about Sue, whose skeleton currently resides at the Field Museum in Chicago, they still puzzle over what caused the smooth-edged holes in her jaw. (She’s named Sue even though her sex is one of her mysteries.)  

Possible explanations for the damage, which has been found in several other specimens’ skulls as well, have included bite wounds and fungal infections, but these culprits don’t match well with the holes’ shapes, sizes and locations, says study coauthor Ewan Wolff of the University of Wisconsin–Madison.

Wolff and his colleagues turned to diseased birds and crocodiles to get a hint about what might have afflicted these T. rex. Wolff found an osprey skull with holes similar to those seen in some of the dinosaur specimens. While it was living, the osprey had been infected with a species of Trichomonas, so the researchers focused on this nasty parasite. Trichomonas commonly infects pigeons, turkeys, chickens and raptors to varying degrees. In severe cases, Trichomonas can cause a filmy infection site to form at the back of the mandible, preventing the animal from eating and drinking. The infection also causes the jaw to rot and leaves visible holes.

Wolff, along with Steven Salisbury, John Horner and David Varricchio, analyzed the skulls of 61 T. rex specimens and found nine (including Sue) with lesions similar to those caused by Trichomonas. The smoothness and location of the holes were similar in the dinosaurs and in infected birds. “Either this was a fantastic coincidence, or this was a very common disease in T. rex,” Wolff says.

Infectious debris that becomes chronically inflamed can ultimately close off the throat. Such an infection may have led Sue to starve, Wolff says. “There are some things you can survive,” Wolff says, “but not having a hole in the back of your throat is not one of them.”

Researchers don’t know how the disease may have been transmitted among dinosaurs. Raptors catch the parasite from eating infected prey, but so far, scientists haven’t found any evidence of infected T. rex meals, Wolff says. “We have lots to look at, but so far, we’re not finding this disease.” The dinosaurs might have also transmitted the disease through face biting and cannibalism, Wolff says. 

The new study is very interesting because "it supports our view that dinosaurs were infected by many pathogens," says paleobiologist George Poinar of Oregon State University in Corvallis. "I think more people will be looking for this now."


Found in: Biology and Paleontology
Comments 3
  • I visited Sue this summer and took some photos of the jaw holes. A museum guide claimed the holes were partially healed. If so, that is not consistent with this article's
    theory. There were also several healed rib fractures and
    a healed leg bone crack. I think a simpler explanation is
    that T rexs lived a combative lifestyle, just look at how
    modern predators such as monitor lizards, crocodiles and
    many birds squabble and fight over food. Even canaries
    can injure and sometimes kill each other in their fights
    over territory.
    Ginger Wolnik Ginger Wolnik
    Oct. 1, 2009 at 1:24pm
  • Trichomonas is spread among pigeons by feeding the squabs crop milk which transmits the infection to the next generation. If the parents are too heavily infected the squab dies, but mild infections can be survived to continue transmission next year. Given that some dinosaurs apparently incubated their eggs, is there any reason to doubt that some of them also fed their young until they were old enough to survive on their own. You don't necessarily need to pass a secretion of a crop gland in order to transmit, at least theoretically, as long as food was carried back to the nest in the dinosaur parent's crop or whatever served as an analogue.
    Daniel Miller Daniel Miller
    Oct. 4, 2009 at 1:08am
  • I've no doubt that parasites afflicted dinosaurs and most every other critter that's ever evolved.

    But to conclude from holes in bone parts of skulls that such parasites MAY have been responsible for any significant mortality to the species by alluding to a known affliction in birds without any evidence of what such parasites had done to the soft tissues within the throat of a T rex seems a little premature.

    It seems clear that T rex and its ancestors were healthy enough to persist in numbers that would leave fossil evidence of their presence. What is NOT clear is that any of the fossils we see today are of individuals that were preferentially fossilized because they might have been afflicted by parasites.

    These beasts were carnivores and were probably not averse to carrion-eating behavior; they were undoubtedly exposed to the potential for contagion such behavior suggests. Yet one EXPECTS them to have evolved fairly effective immunity against disease and parasites associated with that way of making a living, at least long enough to grow into reproducing adults, or we should not expect them to have left many adult-sized fossils at all.

    I agree in general with Ginger Wolnik, but I would ammend her comments to suggest that copulation between these beasts could easily have induced as much damage as territorial behavior. Anyone ever notice how the backs of free-grazing hen chickens on a farm are often denuded of feathers, with their raw backs festered with bleeding sores from the frequent mountings of the resident rooster? The obvious implication predicts there may be a greater number of female T rex fossils that show characteristic evidence of copulatory damage compared to males who may recieve damage from territorial disputes. There may be a difference in the type of damage these different behaviors cause to recognize, but that statistical analysis has not been yet been performed. Meanwhile, that same analysis could better distinguish any damage caused by parasites that presumably may have afflicted BOTH sexes.
    Adolf Schaller Adolf Schaller
    Oct. 4, 2009 at 6:09pm
Post a comment

Please login or register to participate.


Advertisement
Citations & References:
seperator
  • Wolff, E.D.S., S.W. Salisbury, J.R. Horner and D.J. Varricchio. 2009. Common Avian Infection Plagued the Tyrant Dinosaurs. PLoS ONE, published online Sept. 29.
Reader Favorites:
seperator
SN on the Web:
seperator